HN 提问帖：高级工程师的职业前景还有多久被 AI 取代
Ask HN: What is the current trajectory of a senior engineer?
Hacker News 用户 guitarlimeo 发帖提问，探讨随着 LLM 在代码和数学等可判对错领域被强化学习训练，软件架构设计何时也不再需要人类参与。作者质疑开发者所谓“人类仍能引导 agent 和做架构”的说法，认为几年内 90% 的实际编程技能需求会消失，产品负责人等更偏人际能力的角色将更受青睐。
Been recently thinking about this more and more: When the need for a human in the design loop ceases?
Given that LLMs are RL'd to the max with everything that can be given a wrong/right answer (code/maths), what currently is stopping Anthropic, OpenAI et al. from internally building (and maybe buying) datasets of good and bad architecture, and RL'ing that?
Given that LLMs were a fancy autocomplete back in 2024, and now people are talking about building "software factories" with the agents, what in your mind is the stop to this development? Why software architecture would be hard for agents still in a year or two?
Just thinking because I see more and more examples of software developers ignoring this and saying "humans still have a place in guiding the agents and designing the architecture". I think (businesswise) the need for actual software programmer skills is 90% out in a few years I think, and product lead etc people will be favored more as they have more people skills.
it was a good run.
来源：Hacker News · 首页 · news.ycombinator.com